MUSS2520 β Aesthetics and Criticism
University of Leeds | School of Music
π― Course Overview
This module explores the history of musical aesthetics from ancient Greece to contemporary thought. Students will engage with primary texts from philosophers and critics, examining how aesthetic concepts have shaped musical culture and criticism. The course combines historical study with practical application, requiring students to write music reviews informed by aesthetic theories. Key themes include the nature of musical beauty, expression, form, and the social-political role of music.
π Weekly Lecture Themes & Content Focus
- Week 1: Introduction to Themes and Debates
- Key concepts in musical aesthetics
- Historical overview of aesthetic thought
- Week 2: Plato and Greek Views of Music
- Plato’s philosophical ontology and its relation to music
- The Ion: poetry, inspiration and skill
- The Republic: music’s role in education and society
- Week 3: Medieval Attitudes to Music
- Pythagorean harmony and the music of the spheres
- Augustine’s theory of numbers in music
- Al-Farabi and Arabic musical influences
- Week 4: Humanism and Renaissance Opera
- Ficino’s De triplici vita and musical magic
- Renaissance opera prefaces (Peri, Caccini, Monteverdi)
- Week 5: Subjectivity, Sentiment, and Genius
- ScudΓ©ry’s “Of Pleasures”
- Rousseau’s Dictionnaire de Musique
- Diderot’s “Rameau’s Nephew”
- Week 6: Music in German Classical Aesthetics
- Kant’s Critique of Judgement
- KΓΆrner on musical character
- Week 7: Early Romanticism
- Wackenroder’s “Joseph Berglinger”
- Hoffmann’s Beethoven criticism
- Week 8: Idealist Aesthetics and Programme Music
- Hegel’s Aesthetics
- Liszt on Berlioz and program music
- Week 9: Wagner and the Music Drama
- Feuerbach’s philosophical principles
- Wagner’s “Artwork of the Future”
- Week 10: Hanslick, Formalism, and Absolute Music
- Hanslick’s On the Musically Beautiful
- The debate over musical content and form
π Key Readings
- Primary Texts:
- Plato, Ion and Republic (excerpts)
- Augustine, Confessions and De musica (excerpts)
- Kant, Critique of Judgement (excerpts)
- Hanslick, On the Musically Beautiful (chapters 1-3)
- Secondary Sources:
- Carl Dahlhaus, Esthetics of Music
- Edward Lippman, A History of Western Musical Aesthetics
- Andy Hamilton, Aesthetics and Music
π Assessment
The module is assessed through two components:
- Exam (40%):
- 2-hour open-book exam at end of Semester 1
- Section A: Questions on a provided reading extract
- Section B: Choice of essay questions
- Music Reviews (60%):
- 4 reviews (450-550 words each)
- Each review must apply concepts from course readings
- 2 reviews on Semester 1 topics, 2 on Semester 2 topics
π Exam Preparation Guide
Key Skills to Demonstrate
- Textual Analysis: Close reading of philosophical texts
- Historical Context: Relating ideas to their cultural period
- Comparative Analysis: Contrasting different aesthetic positions
- Critical Evaluation: Assessing strengths/weaknesses of arguments
Essay Structure Tips
- Introduction: Define key terms, outline argument
- Historical Context: Situate the ideas in their period
- Analysis: Close reading of relevant texts
- Comparison: Contrast with alternative views
- Evaluation: Critical assessment of arguments
- Conclusion: Summarize findings and implications
π Mock Exam Questions
Section A (Based on provided extract)
Read the following passage from Hanslick’s On the Musically Beautiful then answer the questions below:
“The beautiful is and remains beautiful though it arouse no emotion whatever, and though there be none to contemplate it. In other words, though the beautiful exists for the gratification of an observer, it is independent of him. In this sense we say the beautiful is objective.”
1. How does Hanslick’s concept of musical beauty differ from earlier Romantic views? (30 marks)
Assessment Criteria:
- Understanding of Hanslick’s formalism (40%)
- Comparison with Romantic aesthetics (40%)
- Use of textual evidence (20%)
2. To what extent can Hanslick’s position be reconciled with the idea of music as emotional expression? (30 marks)
Assessment Criteria:
- Analysis of Hanslick’s arguments (40%)
- Evaluation of counter-arguments (40%)
- Logical coherence (20%)
Section B (Choose one question)
3. “At the end of the eighteenth century, it became the custom to speak of the arts as separated completely from the world of the ordinary, mundane, and everyday” (Lydia Goehr). Discuss with reference to at least two writers from the course. (40 marks)
4. How have thinkers instructed listeners to respond to emotionally expressive music, and which approach do you find most valuable? Discuss with reference to at least three writers from different historical periods. (40 marks)