LAW5580M – International Law of Credit and Security

LAW5580M – International Law of Credit and Security

University of Leeds | School of Law

🎯 Course Overview

This module examines the legal framework governing secured transactions and credit arrangements in an international context. Students will explore the different types of security interests, attachment and perfection mechanisms, priority rules, and enforcement procedures. The course also covers quasi-security devices, cross-border issues, and contemporary challenges like security over cryptocurrencies. Through case law analysis and comparative approaches, students will develop a critical understanding of secured transactions law and current reform debates.

📅 Weekly Seminar Themes & Content Focus

  • Week 1: Introduction to Credit and Security
    • Purpose and economic rationale of security
    • Contrast between secured finance and equity finance
    • Types of debt finance: loan credit vs sale credit
  • Week 2: Fixed and Floating Charges
    • Characteristics and legal distinctions between fixed and floating charges
    • Case law development (Re Yorkshire Woolcombers, Spectrum Plus)
    • Practical implications for priority and enforcement
  • Week 3: Attachment and Perfection
    • Requirements for attachment of security interests
    • Different perfection mechanisms: registration, possession, control
    • Financial collateral arrangements
  • Week 4: Enforcement of Security
    • Methods of enforcing different types of security
    • Insolvency considerations and claw-back provisions
    • Appointment of receivers
  • Week 5: Quasi-Security
    • Retention of title clauses
    • Invoice factoring arrangements
    • Comparison with true security interests
  • Week 6: Priority Rules
    • Determining priority between competing security interests
    • Effect of registration on priority
    • Special rules for different types of assets
  • Week 7: Security over Crypto-currencies
    • Legal characterization of crypto-assets
    • Challenges in creating and perfecting security over crypto-currencies
    • Enforcement issues
  • Week 8: Cape Town Convention
    • International framework for security interests in mobile equipment
    • Aircraft Protocol and other specialized regimes
    • Comparison with domestic secured transactions law
  • Week 9: Reform of Secured Transactions Law
    • Law Commission proposals
    • City of London Law Society draft code
    • Comparative approaches (UCC Article 9, PPSA systems)
  • Week 10: Synthesis and Current Issues
    • Critical evaluation of English secured transactions law
    • Emerging challenges in digital assets
    • Future directions for reform

📚 Key Readings

  • Core Textbook: Gullifer, L. (ed) (2017). Goode on Legal Problems of Credit & Security Law (6th student edn, Sweet & Maxwell)
  • Legislation:
    • Companies Act 2006 (especially Part 25)
    • Insolvency Act 1986 (relevant provisions)
    • Financial Collateral Arrangements (No 2) Regulations 2003
  • Key Cases:
    • Re Yorkshire Woolcombers Association Ltd [1903] 2 Ch 284
    • National Westminster Bank Plc v Spectrum Plus Ltd [2005] UKHL 41
    • Re Brumark [2001] UKPC 28
  • Reform Materials:
    • Law Commission, Company Security Interests (2005)
    • City of London Law Society draft code (2016)
    • UNCITRAL Model Law on Secured Transactions (2016)

📝 Assessment

The module is assessed through a 4,000 word coursework essay (100% of the module mark).

Evaluation Criteria: Research and understanding, argument and analysis, structure and coherence, presentation and referencing.

🔍 Essay Writing Guide

Key Tips for Success

  • Develop a clear argument with beginning, middle and end
  • Explain concepts clearly before applying them to your argument
  • Write introduction and conclusion last to ensure coherence
  • Maintain a logical flow between sections without excessive headings
  • Support arguments with relevant case law and statutory provisions

Structure Recommendations

  1. Introduction: Clearly state your position on the question and outline your approach
  2. Main Body: Develop your argument in logical stages with clear transitions
  3. Conclusion: Summarize your argument and its implications

📝 Mock Essay Question

‘The distinction between fixed and floating charges creates unnecessary complexity in English secured transactions law. The Law Commission should have recommended its abolition in its 2005 report.’

Critically discuss this statement.

 

Assessment Criteria:
  • Understanding of fixed/floating charge distinction (25%)
  • Analysis of Law Commission’s approach (25%)
  • Critical evaluation of arguments for/against abolition (30%)
  • Structure and coherence of argument (20%)

Key Issues to Consider:

  • The practical and legal differences between fixed and floating charges
  • The rationale for maintaining the distinction in the Law Commission report
  • Alternative approaches (e.g., UCC Article 9 unitary approach)
  • The implications of abolition for priority rules and enforcement