HUMN2001 – Aesthetics

HUMN2001 – Aesthetics

OCAD University | Instructor: M. Curtis Allen

🎯 Course Overview

This course serves as an introduction to diverse approaches and concepts in philosophical and theoretical thinking about art and aesthetic experience. It explores how aesthetic experience manifests in various aspects of life including art, design, religion, ethics, politics, and everyday experiences. The course examines aesthetic traditions from multiple cultural perspectives, including European, Chinese, Islamic, Japanese, Indigenous, and Black American traditions.

📅 Weekly Lecture Themes & Content Focus

  • Week 1: Introduction and Non-Western Aesthetics
    • Questioning the European origins of aesthetic theory
    • Critical examination of non-Western aesthetics as a colonial construct
  • Week 2: Ancient Foundations
    • Philosophy of art in Ancient Greece (Plato and Aristotle)
    • Aesthetic thought in Ancient China (Mencian philosophy)
    • Islamic aesthetics and alternative ways to knowledge
  • Week 3: Kantian Aesthetics – The Beautiful
    • Disinterestedness and subjective universality
    • Purposiveness without purpose
    • Free vs. adherent beauty
  • Week 4: Kantian Aesthetics – The Sublime
    • Mathematical vs. dynamical sublime
    • The role of reason in aesthetic judgment
    • Comparison with Burke’s theory
  • Week 5: Authorship and Authority
    • Barthes’ “Death of the Author”
    • Structuralist and post-structuralist approaches
    • The reader’s role in creating meaning
  • Week 10: Walter Benjamin and Mechanical Reproduction
    • Cult value vs. exhibition value
    • The concept of aura
    • Aestheticization of politics vs. politicization of art
  • Week 11: Nelson Goodman and Symbol Theory
    • Representation as denotation rather than resemblance
    • Constructivism of representation
    • Relativity of realism
  • Week 12: Islamic Aesthetics
    • Aniconism in Islamic art
    • Sufi approaches to artistic knowledge
    • Principles of Islamic aesthetics: change, uncertainty, and love

📚 Key Readings

  • Week 1: H. Gene Blocker, “Non-Western Aesthetics as a Colonial Invention”
  • Week 2:
    • Plato, “Book X”, Republic
    • Aristotle, Poetics (selections)
    • Tu Wei-Ming, “The Idea of the Human in Mencian Thought”
    • Jale Nejdet Erzen, “Islamic Aesthetics”
  • Week 3-4:
    • Immanuel Kant, “Analytic of the Beautiful”
    • Immanuel Kant, “Analytic of the Sublime”
  • Week 5:
    • Roland Barthes, “The Death of the Author”
  • Week 10:
    • Walter Benjamin, “Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction” (second version)
  • Week 11:
    • Nelson Goodman, “Reality Remade” in Languages of Art
  • Week 12:
    • Jale Nejdet Erzen, “Islamic Aesthetics: An Alternative Way to Knowledge”

📝 Assessment

The course is assessed through the following components:

  • Attendance/Participation (15%)
    • Synchronous discussion or asynchronous written responses
  • Quizzes (30%)
    • 6 quizzes about weekly readings (5% each)
    • Due weekly before Tuesday’s synchronous class
  • Conceptual Elaboration Assignment (25%)
    • Extended analysis of a single aesthetic concept (2-4 pages)
  • Final Project (30%)
    • Option 1: Creative work with written didactic (~1000 words)
    • Option 2: Essay (~2000-2500 words)

📝 Mock Quiz Questions (Week 3 – Kant’s Beautiful)

1. Explain Kant’s concept of “disinterestedness” in judgments of beauty.

 

Assessment Criteria:
  • Accuracy of definition (40%)
  • Comparison with other types of satisfaction (agreeable/good) (30%)
  • Use of textual evidence (30%)

2. What does Kant mean by “purposiveness without purpose”? How does this relate to aesthetic judgment?

 

Assessment Criteria:
  • Clear explanation of concept (50%)
  • Connection to reflective judgment (30%)
  • Example from art/nature (20%)

3. Compare and contrast Kant’s concepts of “free beauty” and “adherent beauty”.

 

Assessment Criteria:
  • Clear distinction between concepts (40%)
  • Examples of each (30%)
  • Relevance to ideal of beauty (30%)

📝 Mock Quiz Questions (Week 4 – Kant’s Sublime)

1. Explain the difference between the mathematically sublime and the dynamically sublime.

 

Assessment Criteria:
  • Clear distinction between types (50%)
  • Role of reason in each (30%)
  • Examples from nature/art (20%)

2. How does Kant’s theory of the sublime differ from Burke’s earlier account?

 

Assessment Criteria:
  • Comparison of key differences (50%)
  • Transcendental vs. empirical approaches (30%)
  • Use of textual evidence (20%)

3. Why does Kant claim that “the sublime is not to be sought in the things of nature but only in our ideas”?

 

Assessment Criteria:
  • Explanation of Kant’s reasoning (50%)
  • Role of human faculties (30%)
  • Connection to moral feeling (20%)

📝 Mock Quiz Questions (Week 5 – Barthes)

1. Explain Barthes’ central argument in “The Death of the Author”.

 

Assessment Criteria:
  • Clear articulation of thesis (50%)
  • Historical context of authorship (30%)
  • Use of textual evidence (20%)

2. How does Barthes’ concept of the “text” differ from traditional notions of the “work”?

 

Assessment Criteria:
  • Explanation of text as “tissue of quotations” (50%)
  • Contrast with author-centered interpretation (30%)
  • Example from literature/art (20%)

3. What role does Barthes assign to the reader in creating meaning?

 

Assessment Criteria:
  • Description of reader’s function (50%)
  • Connection to structuralist/post-structuralist theory (30%)
  • Critical evaluation (20%)